Why does the capture of Borodino’s fortifications leave the Russian army able to withdraw?
At Borodino, the French captured Bagration’s flèches and the Great Redoubt after costly assaults. The Russians counterattacked, shifted their reserves and formed a new line behind the lost positions. In the north, a cavalry diversion slowed Eugène’s effort; in the south, the woods contained Poniatowski. Napoleon held back his infantry reserve. The French kept the field, but the Russian army resumed its retreat toward Moscow.
Stopping the advance on Moscow
After summer retreats, Kutuzov accepted battle on the road to Moscow. The Kolocha protected part of the Russian right, but the left near the Outitsa woods remained more exposed. Fieldworks strengthened this uneven line.
The loss of Shevardino
On 5 September, the French captured the forward work at Shevardino. The Russian left fell back toward the flèches and Semionovskoye. The 6th was spent on reconnaissance, preparations and bridges before the general battle.
Three sectors, several obstacles
In the north, Borodino commanded crossings of the Kolocha. In the center, the Great Redoubt dominated a height. Farther south, the flèches, the Semionovsky ravine and the Outitsa woods required separate attacks; no local success by itself closed the Russian road east.
Reserves prolonged the battle
The Russians drew troops from their right and counterattacked threatened positions. Uvarov and Platov’s intervention later diverted Eugène’s attention. By the time the works fell, both armies were badly worn and a new Russian line still stood.
Specialised modern studyFondation Napoléon, La bataille de la Moskowa par le général baron Lejeune
Sections Le contexte de 1822-1824 et analyse du tableau ; composition postérieure à la bataille.
Understand pictorial groupings of scenes. This article’s account of a redoubt held until night contradicts Eugène’s report and does not settle the tactical chronology.
Specialised archaeological studyM. I. Gonyany et D. B. Solovyev, La batterie de Raïevski comme position d'artillerie
Étude archéologique, pages 1–2 et 6–9 dans la référence antérieure : travaux, emplacements et capacités de la batterie ; non relue intégralement lors de cette reprise.
Specialist check of the fortification and explicit treatment of disagreement over the number of guns; it is not used to invent a phase strength.